Global ETFs vs S&P 500: The key differences

Global ETFs and S&P 500 ETFs both invest in major international businesses, but they offer different exposure to the US stock market. Understand how they compare, what affects their returns and what to consider before investing.

At a glance

01.

S&P 500 ETFs focus on large US companies, while global ETFs also invest in businesses from other countries.

02.

Global ETFs and S&P 500 ETFs can own many of the same US companies, but the amount invested in them can differ.

03.

US stocks can strongly influence both investments. Their returns may differ depending on how companies around the world perform.

Global ETFs vs S&P 500 ETFs: What's the difference?

The main difference between a global ETF and an S&P 500 ETF is where your money is invested. An S&P 500 ETF focuses on large US companies, while a global ETF also invests in businesses from other countries.

S&P 500 ETFs track the S&P 500 Index, which includes the 500 largest US companies. An ETF tracking this index allows you to invest in these businesses through a single fund.

Global ETFs offer a different approach. For example, an ETF tracking the MSCI World Index invests in large and medium-sized companies across developed markets, including the US, Japan and the UK. ETFs tracking the MSCI ACWI or FTSE All-World Index also include emerging markets, such as China and India.

Both approaches provide exposure to major US businesses, but global ETFs also spread your investment across companies in other countries. Understanding this overlap is important when choosing your investments, particularly if you're considering holding both types of ETF, as doing so may increase the proportion of your portfolio invested in US companies across your investment portfolio.

How do global ETFs compare with the S&P 500?

Global ETFs and S&P 500 ETFs can both provide access to major companies through one investment. However, they differ in the countries they cover and how much their performance depends on US stocks.

An S&P 500 ETF gives you access to a broad range of major US businesses, but it does not directly invest in companies listed in other countries.

Global ETFs include companies outside the US, although American businesses can still account for a large share of their investments.

Neither approach is automatically better. The important question is whether you want your investment to focus on the US or include businesses from a wider range of countries.

Why do global ETFs and S&P 500 ETFs have stocks in common?

Global ETFs and S&P 500 ETFs also often have companies in common.

The US is home to many of the world's largest businesses and accounts for a significant share of the global stock market's total value. As a result, US companies typically make up the largest portion of global stock market indices, even those that invest across dozens of countries.

This means that S&P 500 ETFs and global ETFs often hold many of the same well-known US companies, such as Apple, Microsoft and Nvidia. These companies can also represent some of the largest individual investments within both types of ETF.

The difference is that an S&P 500 ETF invests exclusively in US companies by design, while a global ETF has a large allocation to US companies because of their significant share of global stock market value. The exact allocation depends on the index the ETF tracks and how it weights companies.

The amount invested in each company can differ.

For example, a major technology company may represent a larger share of an S&P 500 ETF than a global ETF. If its share price rises or falls, the effect on each fund may therefore be different.

This is worth understanding if you are considering holding both types of ETFs, as you may already own some of the same companies through your global investment.

To understand this further, read Do Global Equity ETFs Hold the Same Stocks?

Three key differences for investors

The main differences between global ETFs and S&P 500 ETFs come down to where they invest, which companies influence returns and how they respond to market movements.

01.

Where your money goes

S&P 500 ETFs focus on US companies, while global ETFs also invest in businesses from other countries.

02.

What drives your returns

US stocks determine S&P 500 returns, while global ETF returns also depend on companies in other markets.

03.

How markets affect your investment

Global and US stocks can perform differently, so ETFs covering different markets may rise or fall by different amounts.

Why can global ETFs and the S&P 500 perform differently?

Global ETFs and S&P 500 ETFs can produce different returns because they do not invest in exactly the same companies or countries.

An S&P 500 ETF depends on the performance of large US businesses. A global ETF also includes companies from other markets, which may perform better or worse than American stocks at different times.

For example, imagine US shares rise strongly while companies in Europe and Asia grow more slowly. An S&P 500 ETF could perform better than a global ETF over that period because its investments are focused on the stronger-performing market.

The reverse is also possible. If US stocks struggle while companies elsewhere perform better, a global ETF may benefit from its investments outside America.

However, this does not mean global ETFs will always outperform when US markets fall. Stock markets around the world can decline together, and global ETFs still have significant US exposure.

The key point is that the difference in returns depends on how the companies and markets within each ETF perform. Past performance does not predict future returns.

Does an S&P 500 ETF offer more growth than global ETFs?

Neither an S&P 500 ETF nor a global equity ETF can guarantee higher investment returns.

The S&P 500 index provides exposure to major American companies, including businesses that have experienced substantial growth over time. However, strong past performance does not mean US stocks will continue to outperform companies in other countries.

Global ETFs offer exposure to a wider range of markets through global indices such as the MSCI World, the MSCI All Country World, the FTSE All World Index, or the MSCI World IMI and the MSCI ACWI IMI indices. This means investors can benefit when companies outside the US perform strongly, although weaker returns in those markets can also reduce overall performance.

For example, an investor holding an ETF following MSCI World or FTSE All-World will still benefit from gains in major US companies included in the fund. However, those gains will be combined with the performance of businesses elsewhere.

The better-performing investment will depend on future market conditions, which cannot be predicted with certainty.

Rather than choosing an ETF based only on recent returns, consider which markets you want to invest in and how much risk you are comfortable taking.

What happens when US stock markets fall?

A fall in US stocks can affect both S&P 500 ETFs and global ETFs, although the impact may differ.

An S&P 500 ETF invests in American companies, so a broad decline in US share prices will directly affect its value.

Global ETFs also hold major US businesses, but they invest in companies from other countries too. If those markets perform better during a US downturn, they may help offset some of the losses.

However, global stock markets are connected. Economic uncertainty, rising interest rates or major financial events can cause share prices to fall across several countries at once.

For this reason, investing globally does not guarantee protection against a decline in the US stock market.

Both types of ETFs can fall significantly in value, and investors may get back less than they originally invested.

How could different market conditions affect your ETF?

Global ETFs and S&P 500 ETFs may respond differently as stock markets change. These examples show how their investments could be affected under different conditions.

Not all stock markets move in the same direction, and neither do companies of different sizes. Sometimes US companies lead the way. At other times, businesses in emerging markets or smaller companies may perform better.

The markets and company sizes included in your ETF can make a difference to your investment returns. Here's how ETFs tracking different indices might be affected in various market situations.

These are illustrative scenarios, not performance forecasts. The returns of any ETF depends on the performance and relative weight of its holdings, as well as other factors such as currency movements.

What does this mean when choosing an ETF?

  • Two things to consider are which markets and company sizes you want to invest in, and whether you prefer an all-in-one ETF that includes a broad range of companies in proportions determined by the index, or a combination of separate ETFs that lets you choose those proportions yourself.
  • An S&P 500 ETF concentrates on large US businesses. An MSCI World ETF extends your investment to large and medium-sized companies in other developed markets. An MSCI World IMI ETF includes smaller businesses in those markets too.
  • If you also want emerging markets in your investment, ETFs tracking the MSCI ACWI or FTSE All-World indices include them alongside developed markets. An MSCI ACWI IMI ETF goes further in terms of company-size coverage, including smaller businesses across both developed and emerging markets.
  • There isn't one approach that suits everyone. You can choose an ETF that brings together the markets and company sizes you want in one investment, or combine different ETFs to decide for yourself how much and when to invest in each.

The table shows why the countries and company sizes included in an ETF can make a difference to its returns. However, investing across more markets and company sizes does not guarantee a better outcome.

Should you own both a global ETF and an S&P 500 ETF?

You can hold both a global ETF and an S&P 500 ETF, but it is important to understand how the investments work together.

Global ETFs following MSCI World, MSCI ACWI and FTSE All-World already include many major US companies. Adding an S&P 500 ETF could therefore increase the amount of your money invested in businesses you already own.

For example, imagine you invest £1,000 in a global ETF and later add £500 to an S&P 500 ETF. Your total investment would be £1,500, but some of the same US companies would appear in both funds.

This means your portfolio would become more focused on American stocks, rather than simply adding a completely different group of companies.

This is not automatically a problem. Some investors may deliberately want more exposure to US businesses. However, it is worth considering whether that additional investment fits your goals.

Before holding both ETFs, compare their largest companies and consider how much of your overall portfolio would depend on US stock market performance.

What should you check before choosing an ETF?

Before investing, consider how much exposure you want to US companies and how each ETF would fit alongside your existing investments.

Decide what you want to invest

Consider whether you want to focus on US companies or invest across a wider range of countries.

Check your US exposure

Global ETFs already invest heavily in US businesses. Review their country breakdown to understand how much.

Look at the largest companies

Compare the biggest holdings in each ETF to see which businesses appear in both investments.

Consider your investment goals

Think about your timeframe, how much risk you can accept and whether the ETF fits your existing investments.

Which approach could fit your investment goals?

Choosing between a global ETF and an S&P 500 ETF depends on the type of investment you want to make.

An S&P 500 ETF focuses on large American companies. This may appeal to investors who specifically want to invest in the US stock market and are comfortable with their returns depending on that market.

A global ETF following MSCI World, MSCI ACWI or FTSE All-World, MSCI World IMI and MSCI ACWI IMI provides access to companies across several countries and company sizes. This may appeal to investors who want to include businesses outside the US rather than concentrating their equity investments in one market.

Both approaches can be used for long-term investing, but neither guarantees positive returns. The value of your investment can rise or fall depending on stock market conditions.

If you already own other investments, consider how a new ETF would change your overall exposure. In particular, check whether you would be adding companies you already hold.

The most useful starting point is to understand what each ETF invests in and whether that fits your goals, rather than trying to predict which market will perform best.

Frequently asked questions

Conclusion: key takeaways to remember

Understand where your money goes

S&P 500 ETFs focus on US companies, while global ETFs also invest in businesses across other countries.

Expect some shared companies

Global ETFs and S&P 500 ETFs can hold many of the same US businesses, although the amounts invested may differ.

Returns can differ over time

US and global stock markets can perform differently, affecting how much each ETF rises or falls.

Consider your overall US exposure

Before holding both types of ETFs, check whether you would increase your investment in US companies you already own.

Continue exploring global investing

Decorative

Do global equity ETFs hold the same stocks?

Learn why global ETFs can own many of the same companies and what this means for your investments.

Read the article
Happy woman using a smartphone and looking out of a train window. BlackRock; iShares; Portrait; individual investor

Getting started with global investing

Learn how to start investing globally, choose an ETF, understand risks, and build a long-term investment approach.

Read the article
Decorative

Global investing: A guide to diversification

Learn how global investing spreads exposure across companies, sectors, and countries, and understand the risks.

Read the article

Ready to start investing?

Getting started with investing doesn't have to be complicated. With a clear plan and a long-term perspective, even small steps can make a difference over time. Many investors begin with a few simple steps:

Define your goals

Consider what you want to achieve and how investing fits into your plans.

Open an investment account

You'll need an investing account with an online investment platform, bank or provider.

Choose a suitable investment approach

A diversified portfolio may include a mix of asset classes, such as stocks, bonds and cash, often accessed through vehicles like ETFs.

Start investing regularly

Investing regularly means buying at different times and prices, which can help spread the impact of market ups and downs over time.

MKTG1126-H-6086334-EXP1127